
What To Do When The Breath Is Not For You
The breath is the traditional focus of meditation, but for some people, it simply doesn't work. Trauma, illness. or injury can make breathwork more trouble than it's worth. Thankfully, mindfulness doesn't care. Any object can be used to anchor our focus. This talk breaks down some common alternative options to the breath, providing everyone with an option to comfortably practice mindfulness meditation to their fullest.
Transcript
To be clear,
Mindfulness is not the act of meditating.
It is the state that arises from our meditation practice.
Therefore,
Mindfulness is not dependent on the use of the breath as a meditation object.
Anything can be used.
Sounds,
Sights,
Physical sensations,
Thoughts,
And even awareness itself.
In fact,
If we want to integrate the benefits into our daily lives,
It is vital that we explore mindfulness across a broad spectrum of meditation objects.
That way,
We will have the tools of mindfulness ready to employ,
Whenever and wherever we need them.
What is the point of our practice if the benefits do not transcend the meditation mat?
The traditional object of mindfulness meditation is the breath.
It is used because it is always available and is constantly changing.
The breath provides an anchor on which we can focus our minds.
When we notice our attention shifting,
We simply and gently return it back to the sensation of the breath at the nose.
Unfortunately,
Some people struggle with breath work.
Perhaps due to anxiety,
Past trauma,
Illness,
Allergies,
Or other unknown reasons.
For some people,
The act of closing the eyes and focusing on the breath is challenging,
Confronting,
Or even triggering.
The traditional response to these kind of issues is to treat these negative symptoms as you would any other distraction.
That is to acknowledge them and gently return the focus back to the breath.
While I encourage this approach to be attempted,
I strongly advocate that all meditators,
Especially beginning practitioners,
Do not push through significant emotional duress.
You do not need to martyr yourself,
Nor do you need to grit your teeth and bear significant emotional or even physical pain.
Particularly not when you're first starting out.
Later sections of this book will explore how experienced meditators can choose to use pain itself as a meditation object.
But for the moment,
It is enough to know that they do so with the knowledge and wisdom of hundreds of hours of accrued mat time.
So if you find that you are not coping with a particular meditation object,
Practice,
Or pose,
Simply change it.
So let's explore some different options that you have available to you.
Mindful walking.
Mindful walking is traditionally used by monks and retreat goers as a complement to breath work.
By alternating between sitting and walking,
Practitioners can say meditating for hours on end.
Instead of the breath,
The physical sensations of the feet hitting the ground are used as the meditation object.
And like the breath,
These sensations are constantly changing and always available.
This walking is done with good posture and very slowly,
Perhaps at about a third of your normal walking pace.
Hands are clasped in front or gently behind the back.
Meditation.
Mindful walking.
Find a space where you can freely walk in a circle,
Like a lounge room,
Hallway,
Or secluded garden.
Start a timer for five minutes.
Begin walking slowly at about a third of your regular pace.
Draw your attention to the sensations at your feet.
Notice the heel,
Base,
And ball of your foot hitting and leaving the floor.
If your mind wanders,
Gently return your focus back to the sensations coming from your feet.
Repeat for the duration of the session.
Give that a try now.
There is some stigma that may be associated with walking slowly in circles alone.
To some it may feel silly or even crazy.
Indeed,
The first few times I tried mindful walking,
I struggled to move past the feeling of self-consciousness that arose.
You do get used to it,
And of course,
Those feelings are another form of distraction and should be treated as such.
Nevertheless,
These feelings can initially at least be a block to successful practice.
Remember,
Our goal is not to meditate correctly,
But to attain mindfulness.
While the traditional approaches to mindfulness meditation work and work well,
They are a finger pointing to the moon,
And as such,
Ultimately serve as a guide,
Not as doctrine.
There is a risk of religiously following a practice for the practice's sake,
And subsequently losing sight of the real point of why we started in the first place.
Provided that we adhere to the principles of mindfulness meditation,
We can alter the way we meditate.
When practicing mindful walking,
I prefer to walk outside and not in circles.
A common variation I will use will be to walk around my block at about half of my regular walking pace.
Alternatively,
I will use a treadmill at one kilometre per hour and remain in place in my home.
In both of these variations,
I keep my focused attention on the sensations at my feet and my broad awareness on.
But more on that later in the section,
Broad awareness.
Mindful walking can be used alongside or instead of formal seated,
Breath-focused mindfulness.
Remember,
It is not the focus of our mindful attention that matters,
But the act of focusing.
So whether we focus on the breath,
The sensations of our feet,
Or any of the following suggestions,
Mindfulness can and still be attained.
But with that said,
Some people initially click with certain types and objects of mindful focus.
So try them all and stall them away for future use.
I practice mindful walking whenever I'm walking alone or feeling too restless for a traditional seated session.
Mindful Movement Yoga is the traditional form of mindful movement.
It was initially created to keep the meditator's body strong enough to practice formal sitting for hours on end,
While also standing as a viable meditation practice in its own right.
Unfortunately,
Many Western schools have all but entirely dropped the mindful aspect,
Opting instead to push solely for the physical benefits.
These are no doubt amazing,
But through the application of mindful focus,
We stand to gain even more from it.
Mindful movement is practiced in a similar way to mindful walking.
You choose one aspect of the activity to become your mindful focus,
And when your mind wanders,
You gently return your focus back to it.
For yoga,
You may choose to focus on the feeling of the stretch,
Noting what it feels like,
How strong those feelings are,
As well as observing any related mental phenomena that may accompany it.
Or you could choose to focus on your feelings of change over your body as you move through your poses.
Make sure to move slowly and deliberately,
At least at first.
Glimpse Mindful Stretching Notice what your arms and shoulders feel like at this moment.
Then gently and slowly stretch them out in front of you.
Notice your intention to move your arms,
Then notice them moving.
What does it feel like when they are fully outstretched?
Give this a try now.
With practice,
This same approach can be applied to all forms of physical movement and exercise.
What does it feel like to dance or to move through a martial arts kata?
When lifting,
Note how your muscles are feeling.
Observe how your body goes through the practiced repetitive motions,
Like shooting a hoop or riding a bike.
I practice mindful movement whenever I am stretching,
As well as during the warm-up and cool-down components of my daily exercise sessions.
Mindful Looking As a formal practice,
Mindful looking is often done with a candle,
A flower,
A religious or spiritual icon,
Or a portrait.
But any object will work just as well.
You simply choose an aspect of the object,
For example its color,
Size,
Shape,
Tone,
Or texture to focus on,
Or the object in its entirety,
And use that point of focus as an anchor for your attention.
When your mind wanders,
Gently return your focus back to observation.
Let's give it a try.
Glimpse Looking at your hands For the next 30 seconds,
Hold your hands out in front of you and just observe what you see,
Mentally noting the colors,
Shapes,
Textures,
And shadows.
Attempt to look at your hands as if it were the first time you've ever seen them.
Try not to overlay any judgment,
Comment,
Meaning,
Or thought.
If your mind wanders,
Gently return your focus back to your hands.
Mindful Looking is a great on-the-go practice.
You can perform it when you find yourself with a few spare seconds here or there,
Waiting in line,
Stuck in traffic,
Taking an elevator,
Or when you are waiting to be served,
All work well.
Rather than checking social media again,
You can instead take these moments to delve deeper into your practice.
Over time,
You will find that you are far more observant.
You will begin to notice small changes in shape,
Shadow,
And color,
And will develop a greater appreciation of the inherent beauty of the world around you.
You can even practice mindful looking with your eyes closed.
Glimpse Looking with closed eyes For the next 30 seconds,
Close your eyes,
While keeping your vision engaged.
Look upon the darkness as if it were a night sky.
Notice the quality of your visual field.
Watch how it moves,
Changes,
And flows.
Are there any colors?
Do any shapes coalesce together?
If your mind wanders,
Gently return your focus to what you can see with your eyes closed.
Give it a try now.
I use mindful looking throughout my day to trigger ongoing mindfulness,
As well as when I am observing nature or art.
Mindful Hearing Sounds of any sort can be used as an object of mindful focus.
Perhaps it could be the simple observation of the noises coming from the environment,
Or it could be the purposeful playing of a certain music track during a formal session.
It could even be something as subtle as a heartbeat,
Or the sounds arising from breathing.
To practice mindful hearing,
You simply draw your attention to the sound that you wish to observe.
Attempt to hear all of it,
Without judgment and without filter.
Do not strain or try and force yourself to search for every small nuance.
Simply let the sound come to your ears.
Glimpse Mindful Hearing For the next 30 seconds,
Close your eyes and draw your attention to what you can hear.
Notice how the sounds change,
Including the volume,
Tone and type that you hear.
Notice the gaps between the sounds.
Give this a try now.
You may find that focusing on non-verbal sounds like nature,
Music,
Machinery or traffic,
Will be easier than with spoken words.
This is because humans are language processing machines.
We've been practicing our entire lives to turn the sounds coming out of the mouths of those around us,
Into something that has meaning.
Thus,
It may be hard to listen mindfully to the sounds of words without judgment or interpretation.
The next time you find yourself able to listen in on a conversation that you're not involved in,
Give it a try.
Attempt to simply hear the sounds of the words and not take the next step to interpret them.
With practice,
You may be able to witness the quick and subtle conversion of words into meaning and then the triggering of your memory.
Another approach is to listen to words spoken in a foreign language.
You will have little context to hang meaning onto and thus will be better equipped to hear the sounds simply and mindfully.
Focus on the rhythm,
Tone,
Volume and pacing of the sound as it hits your ears.
I practice mindful hearing while listening to music and the sounds of nature throughout the day.
Present state awareness.
You can choose to focus your mindful attention on one object as described above or you could choose to shift your focus through different objects for the duration of the meditation session.
With present state awareness,
We cycle through all five senses,
Drawing attention to what we can see,
Hear,
Feel,
Taste and smell.
Not only does this practice work great as a form of mindfulness meditation,
But it also is extremely grounding and thus an amazing anti-anxiety technique.
I use this whenever I feel the onset of a panic attack or need to slow down a racing and ruminating mind.
By focusing on our senses,
We are directing our attention out of our head and into the present moment.
We are grounding ourselves in what is happening now,
Not what was happening or what we think may happen.
Meditation.
Present state awareness.
Take five slow and deep breaths.
In through the nose and out through the mouth.
Do not force this breathing pattern.
You should feel comfortable and not strained.
Continue breathing this way with five breaths for each of the following senses.
Focus your attention onto what you can feel.
What does the ground feel like?
Can you feel the wind?
Is there any pressure,
Tension or sensation coming from inside your body?
What do your clothes feel like?
Are you hungry?
Do you feel hot or cold?
Have you felt anything new?
Move your attention onto what you can see.
Notice the lines,
The colors,
The shapes,
The textures.
Notice the play of light and the contrasting of shadows.
Have you seen anything new?
Move your attention onto what you can hear.
What sounds are coming to your ears?
Are they natural or man-made?
Can you hear music or conversation?
What is the pitch and tone?
Is it loud or quiet?
Have you heard anything new?
Move your attention onto what you can smell.
Focus on the air coming into your nose.
Are there any smells that you instantly recognize?
Are there some that you can't place?
Is there an undertone?
Have you smelt anything new?
Move your attention onto what you can taste.
Focus on your mouth and tongue.
Are there any residual tastes in your mouth?
Perhaps you can still taste some of the strong flavors from your last meal,
Or coffee,
Or toothpaste.
Have you tasted anything new?
Give that a try now.
You can vary the present state awareness meditation by choosing to repeat the cycle through all senses multiple times,
Or you could choose to focus specifically on one or two of them.
I like to use present state awareness throughout the day to ground myself.
I do not always go through all of the whole process as just described.
Instead,
I opt for just a recognition of what is coming from my senses in that moment.
Glimpse.
The five senses.
Take a moment and ask yourself the following.
What can I see?
What can I feel?
What can I hear?
What can I taste?
What can I smell?
Give it a try now.
Any object can be used as the focus of our mindful attention.
Provided we observe it without judgment,
It does not matter what we are observing.
Mindfulness will come.
In part two of this book,
We will delve into the more subtle and esoteric applications of our mindful focus,
Moving away from physical sensations and into the realm of thought,
Focus,
And consciousness itself.
But for the moment,
I encourage you to apply your mindful focus wherever possible,
And across all of your senses.
I use present state awareness as a counter to anxiety and panic attacks,
And as a grounding exercise at the beginning of a formal meditation session.
Mindful Eating Just a small warning when it comes to mindful eating.
You may find that,
Until this point,
You've not been paying much attention to the food you eat,
And thus,
You may be eating things that you do not enjoy.
I've received many comments lamenting the fact that this practice has ruined certain foods,
But the reality is,
Is that they were not simply mindful of the food they were putting into their mouth.
They never really liked it,
But now they know.
This example is a microcosm of some of the impacts that mindfulness meditation can have on your life.
With practice,
You will find yourself more in tune with your inner world,
And more a world of the impact that the environment is having on you.
Thus,
You may realize that certain aspects of your life may now need to be tweaked or changed.
Work,
Hobbies,
Relationships,
Location,
Dress style,
And life goals may no longer fit.
Making these changes may hurt,
But it is worth doing.
Doing so will result in a life that is far more in line with who and what you truly are.
This will lead to a deeper sense of satisfaction and happiness.
The reality is that you never liked that food,
And continuing to eat it mindlessly may sustain your body,
But it will not satisfy your soul.
Similarly,
You may find some aspects of your life that are comfortable and safe,
But nonetheless not satisfying.
On the other hand,
You may discover that you are not at all happy where you are,
And simply did not realize it,
Or were avoiding even thinking about it.
Regardless of the cause,
Changes must be made,
And they must be made mindfully.
So,
Start with your food,
And expand outwardly from there.
Glimpse.
Mindful eating.
Take one small piece of food,
Like a grape or a piece of chocolate.
Consider where it was grown or made,
And the process that it took to get to your plate.
Observe it closely.
Smell it.
Look at it.
Feel it.
Then slowly and deliberately place it into your mouth.
Notice your intention to chew,
And then slowly do so.
What does it taste like?
Give it a try now.
I use mindful eating to help regulate my intake of sugary items,
Control my cravings,
And slow down the rate of food consumption to better aid with digestion.
This talk was taken from the book,
Mindfulness,
A guidebook to the present moment.
4.8 (13)
Recent Reviews
Shirlee
July 7, 2021
Thank you for addressing this. It is a real issue for me due to a lung condition. I have worried often about my inability to take deep breath. Thank you again! ❤️
